Looking beyond labels
In response to your Dec. 27 editorial “Being locked up is punishment enough,” I would like to submit the following opinion.
Thank you for looking beyond the label of prisoner and seeing inmates as human beings.
I am an inmate at Idaho Correctional Institution-Orofino. Recently while counseling with a minister at the prison, I expressed remorse for the mistakes that brought me to prison. I asked, “Do you think I have redeeming value after the things I’ve done wrong?”
He immediately sat bolt upright, looked me in the eye and said, “Brian, I’ve been counseling with people and accepting confessions for most of my life. I have yet to get to know someone well and find that they have not committed an offense — however, minor it may be — that could be arrestable. The only difference between us and you is that we live on opposite sides of a security fence.”
This leads me to wonder: If the criteria for vulnerable people to qualify for a potentially life-saving vaccine is that you’ve never made a grievous mistake, would anyone qualify for the vaccine?
Brian McNitt
Orofino
Dam breaching makes sense
What appears to be “common sense” often does not pan out. In the 1970s, it became clear that the recently constructed lower Snake River dams were killing Idaho’s juvenile salmon and steelhead. The Bonneville Power Administration then built hatcheries to replace lost harvest and funded construction of barges to transport smolts to below Bonneville Dam.
In the 1980s, 85 to 90 percent of Snake River smolts were captured and transported. The result? In the 1990s, Snake River sockeye were listed as endangered, and steelhead and spring, summer and fall chinook were listed as threatened. They remain so today.
The “common sense” measure of barging did not prevent the decline of Snake River salmon and steelhead caused by the lower Snake River dams.
Barging and other means to improve smolt survival have been studied by the Fish Passage Center for 40 years. The stress of passing through a turbine bypass system to be collected for barging reduces smolt survival by 9 to 13 percent. Additionally, adult salmon and steelhead barged as juveniles migrate upriver slower, stray more and fall back over dams more often than do adults from non-transported juveniles. Smolt barging has continued, but it is part of a spread-the-risk approach, along with spill.
Common sense to me, and many others, including Idaho Rep. Mike Simpson, is that Idaho salmon and steelhead need a river.
Breach the lower Snake River dams and Fish Passage Center studies have determined smolt survival will increase dramatically. Our salmon and steelhead will recover.
Richard Scully
Lewiston
