1957 — Texas Sul Ross State (Texas)
1958 — San Diego State (Calif.)
1959 — Southern-Baton Rouge (La.)
1960 — Whitworth (Wash.)
1961 — East Carolina (N.C.)
1962 — Georgia Southern
1963 — Sam Houston State (Texas)
1964 — West Liberty State (W.Va.)
1965 — Carson-Newman (Tenn.)
1966 — Linfield (Ore.)
1967 — New Mexico Highlands
1968 — William Jewell (Mo.)
1969 — William Carey (Miss.)
1970 — Eastern Michigan
1971 — Linfield (Ore.)
1972 — La Verne (Calif.)
1973 — U.S. International (Calif.)
1974 — Lewis (Ill.)
1975 — Lewis (Ill.)
1976 — Lewis (Ill.)
1977 — David Lipscomb (Tenn.)
1978 — Emporia State (Kan.)
1979 — David Lipscomb (Tenn.)
1980 — Grand Canyon (Ariz.)
1981 — Grand Canyon (Ariz.)
1982 — Grand Canyon (Ariz.)
1983 — Lubbock Christian (Texas)
1984 — Lewis-Clark State (Idaho)
1985 — Lewis-Clark State (Idaho)
1986 — Grand Canyon (Ariz.)
1987 — Lewis-Clark State (Idaho)
1988 — Lewis-Clark State (Idaho)
1989 — Lewis-Clark State (Idaho)
1990 — Lewis-Clark State (Idaho)
1991 — Lewis-Clark State (Idaho)
1992 — Lewis-Clark State (Idaho)
1993 — St. Francis (Ill.)
1994 — Kennesaw State (Ga.)
1995 — Bellevue (Neb.)
1996 — Lewis-Clark State (Idaho)
1997 — Brewton-Parker (Ga.)
1998 — Albertson (Idaho)
1999 — Lewis-Clark State (Idaho)
2000 — Lewis-Clark State (Idaho)
2001 — Birmingham-Southern (Ala.)
2002 — Lewis-Clark State (Idaho)
2003 — Lewis-Clark State (Idaho)
2004 — Cumberland (Tenn.)
2005 — Oklahoma City
2006 — Lewis-Clark State (Idaho)
2007 — Lewis-Clark State (Idaho)
2008 — Lewis-Clark State (Idaho)
2009 — Lubbock Christian (Texas)
2010 — Cumberland (Tenn.)
2011 — Concordia (Calif.)
2012 — Tennessee Wesleyan
2013 — Faulkner (Ala.)
2014 — Cumberland (Tenn.)
2015 — Lewis-Clark State (Idaho)
2016 — Lewis-Clark State (Idaho)
2017 — Lewis-Clark State (Idaho)
2018 — Southeastern (Fla.)
2019 — Tennessee Wesleyan
2020 — tournament canceled, pandemic
2021 — Georgia Gwinnett
2022 — Southeastern (Fla.)
