She says sharing the holidays feels unnatural

Jann Blackstone

My wife and I recently broke up after 18 years of marriage. It was because I have found someone new and probably didn’t handle things as I should.

Now my family has broken into factions, and everyone is upset and taking sides. I’m at a loss as to what to do. What’s good ex-etiquette?

Rarely do people who have affairs stop to consider the far-reaching effects their decision has on not only their partner, but also their family members.

I remember working with a family who was trying to navigate just this situation. When the daughter confronted her father about what he had done to her, his comment was, “I did nothing to you. I did this to your mother.”

It was quite an eye-opening response — for everyone — including the father. Prior to voicing this, he thought that his decision affected only him. In that split second he realized the gravity of his decision to go outside of his marriage. When you are a family, every decision you make affects every member of the family in some way.

But that sobering fact does not help you at this point. You have already made the choice and now want to know how to repair the fallout. That’s tough one.

You didn’t say what your future plans are: stay and rebuild your marriage, or leave permanently and attempt to form a new relationship. You should know going in that it’s rare that two people who had an affair marry at all, and then are still married after five years. Dishonesty is not a good foundation for any relationship.

More relationships seem to be weathering infidelity than ever before. However, it takes work to get on the other side of something like this. You are going to have to rebuild from scratch, and you probably won’t be able to do it by yourself. Get help from a therapist who specializes things like this.

Important components to survival begin with a heartfelt apology — possibly two or three or 600 times — genuine remorse and ending with complete transparency in the future. What does transparency look like? You volunteer as much information as possible.

If she asks where you are going or where you have been, you tell her the truth. If she wants to see your phone, you hand it to her. You give her all your passwords and answer every question she asks. For how long? For as long as it takes. That’s where that therapist can guide you. Your wife may throw up roadblocks to test your commitment. If you want to fix this, you must have patience. Both you and your wife must be truly dedicated to putting it back together.

Your relationship with your family members actually may be more difficult to repair. Children love their parents differently than parents love each other. That love is often the glue that allows two people to repair something like this, but a child’s anger at feeling betrayed by a parent is completely different.

Remorse and a vow not to repeat the same behavior is a start, as well as doing your best to demonstrate respect for their mother. You forgot that one in the past, and believe me, it registered. Consult that therapist to guide you through the process here, as well.

I think my readers will be interested in your progress. Keep us posted.

Blackstone is founder of Bonus Families,, and may be contacted at


Recommended for you